My memories of this dilemma had faded over the years – until I retired! That was when I was shocked to remember that my driver’s license, my passport, and many other documents and records listed my birthdate as February 9, 1947 – but – Social Security listed by birthdate as February 2, 1947. Suddenly I realized that a problem was looming in the very near future – how could I receive my social security and my retirement pension benefits with two different birthdays. With great concern I called the office that administers my pension benefits with my question: “What do we do now?” They responded that the best way to solve the dilemma was for them to change their records to match the information at Social Security. Problem solved.
It quickly became a fun game to go to doctor’s appointments. When they inquired if anything had changed, I responded “Yes – I have different insurance – and – by the way – I also have a new birthday.”
Then I would tell this story – which is true: When I was growing up I celebrated my birthday on February 2 – because that is what my birth certificate said. During those years I opened my Social Security account and got my first driver’s license – in Kansas.
A few years later I needed to secure a Passport for a college choir tour to Europe and was not able to locate my birth certificate – so I requested another certified copy from the State of Oklahoma. When it arrived – I remember being very surprised – the 2 in the date of my birth had been crossed out and replaced with a 9 with initials approving the change – so without concern I moved to celebrating my birthday on February 9.
However, I do remember asking my mother which date was correct – and – much to my surprise she responded: “I don’t remember” – my response (which I did not speak out loud) was: “Weren’t you there?” Again – problem solved – or so I thought.
Recently – during the admission process for both my heart catheterization and my eye surgery – the discrepancy again posed an issue – my primary ID (driver’s license) and my date of birth for my primary and secondary insurance coverage listed two different numbers for my date of birth. Now – once again – I realize the need to locate my birth certificate which clearly indicates both numbers – even though one is crossed out – and begin the process of getting the numbers to be the same on all of my documents.
Over a year ago we did locate a newspaper article that carried a very brief article about my birth – it stated: A seven pound son was born to Mrs. Doris Mitchell, Sunday evening. He has been named Thomas Eugene. The article was printed in a weekly newspaper in the little town of Stilwell, Oklahoma located about 45 minutes from Bunch where I was born. This edition of the paper was published on Thursday, February 13, 1947 on page 7. So if Sunday evening refers to the previous Sunday evening – then February 9 would be correct. However, this requires that the news of my birth in 1947 made it from Bunch to Stilwell in time to be included in the coming edition of the paper. This seems highly unlikely to me. I believe that Sunday evening likely refers to the previous Sunday evening which would have been February 2 – so – the dilemma is unsolved.
I think I will request another certified copy of my birth certificate just to see what the current version might list as my birth date – hopefully, it will still be either February 2 or February 9. As a result – one of the funny things that happened on the way to the pulpit is that I do not know for sure the date in February, 1947 that I was born – but – I do know that it was on a Sunday evening.